Effingham Daily News, Effingham, IL

Local News

June 6, 2014

Accused's man sister focus of closing arguments in Yoder case

EFFINGHAM — Elizabeth Walters was the main topic of closing arguments Friday in the first-degree murder trial of Charles Douglas Yoder.

Yoder, 53, has been standing trial in Effingham County Circuit Court this week in connection with the May 7, 2013, stabbing death of Ted L. Debany. Debany, 52, had been sharing a home with Walters, Yoder's younger half-sister, at the time of his death.

Walters was the key prosecution witness in the trial of her half-brother.

In their respective closing arguments, State's Attorney Bryan Kibler and Public Defender Scott Schmidt differed wildly on their characterization of Walters' credibility.

Kibler conceded that Walters probably won't become the pillar of the community anytime soon. But Kibler maintained that Walters was telling the truth when she told police that Yoder stabbed Debany after an altercation between Debany and another man at their home.

"Elizabeth Walters may be a lot of things, but liar is not one of them," Kibler said. "She may be on too many pain medications, and she may spend too much time mixing alcohol with those meds.

"She may not even be somebody you would want over at your home for Sunday dinner," Kibler added. "But ultimately, she's telling the truth about the most important detail in this case."

Kibler said Walters' credibility was bolstered by circumstantial evidence in the case.

"Play the game of process of elimination. Once you play that game, it's clear that only one man could have done it, and it's that man," said Kibler, as he pointed at Yoder, who has been impeccably dressed in a suit and tie throughout this week's proceedings.

Kibler said Walters should be eliminated as a suspect because she stayed at her home in an effort to care for Debany after the stabbing. Likewise, he said, Clifford Arnett — the man identified as the victim of an attack by Debany shortly before the stabbing — should also be eliminated.

Text Only
Local News
  • Man fatally shot in Pana standoff, officer wounded

    Illinois State Police(ISP) and Christian County Sheriff's Office are investigating a shooting that occurred on Tuesday, July 29, in rural Christian County that involved ISP SWAT, a Pana Police officer and an armed offender.

    July 29, 2014

  • City to determine contribution A request by Effingham Park District representatives for a million dollars to help construct the Richard E. Workman Sports and Wellness Center is being considered at a special Effingham City Council meeting this evening.Some commissioners questioned

    July 29, 2014

  • 7-29 Filming PRIMARY Effingham grad returns to make film Travis Long says he learned a lot from directing his first full-length feature several years ago.“Kill Me Now was a learning experience, both in shooting and distribution,” the 1998 Effingham High School graduate said.With a full production crew and

    July 29, 2014 2 Photos

  • McCarter.jpg Some lawmakers donate pay

    Illinois lawmakers restoring their pay after years of furlough days has prompted some state representatives to give back to their communities — a move some local lawmakers call a political one.

    July 27, 2014 3 Photos

  • Distance learning catching on in area

    In what appears to be a growing trend among rural school districts, a third area school district may join an existing academic cooperative.

    July 27, 2014

  • Joshua Robison.jpg Opinion: God doesn't care about party affiliation

    Reflecting on what we politely refer to in this country as “political discourse,” I am often struck by how convinced many people seem to be that their sides' specific policies and personalities are the only way to save us all from utter ruin.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Ron W.jpg Opinion: Column break just that -- a break

    ‘Hey, Ron. You didn’t have a column this week. What’s the deal? It’s the reason I buy a paper on Thursdays.”

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • Isom.jpg Opinion: It's about time

    Finally, someone else speaks up and it’s about time.
    I applaud Ron Worman and welcome him to take a seat on my bandwagon. His addressing the proliferation of signs of every description, virtually everywhere one looks, is a welcome additional voice — even though rare.

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • Feds: Effingham County was meeting place for underage sex tryst

    An Ohio man has been indicted by a federal grand jury on charges that he traveled out of state to meet an underage person in Effingham County for sexual activity.

    July 25, 2014

  • Jail inmate attempts suicide

    An unscheduled cell check is credited for saving the life of an Effingham County Jail inmate who tried to hang himself early Thursday morning.

    July 25, 2014

AP Video

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.